Skip to content

NOW CONSIGNING FALL & WINTER STYLES

NOW HIRING FOR PART-TIME AND WEEKENDS! APPLY HERE

Shop
- Buy Gift Cards Here!
- New Arrivals
- Accessories
  
  Bags/Luggage
  Wallets
  Soap/Skincare
  Ties
  Sunglasses
  Belts & Belt Buckles
  Cologne
  Glasses
  Readers
  Hats
  Knives
  Misc. Items
  Gloves
  All
- Athletic Wear
  
  T-Shirts
  Long Sleeve T-Shirts
  Pullovers
  Pants
  Shorts
  Jackets
  All
- Furniture
- Home Decor
- Jewelry
  
  Watches
  Cufflinks
  Rings
  Necklaces
  All
- Motorcycle Gear
  
  Jackets
  T-Shirts
  Boots
  Jeans
  Chaps
  Helmets
  Accessories
  All
- Outerwear
  
  Jackets
  Coats
  Pullovers
  Vests
  All
- Pants & Jeans
  
  Jeans
  Pants
  Athletic Pants
  All
- Shirts
  
  Short Sleeve
  Casual Shirts
  Dress Shirts
  All
- Shoes
  
  Shoes
  Sneakers
  Sandals
  Boots
  All
- Shorts
  
  Casual Shorts
  Athletic Shorts
  Swimwear
  All
- Suits & Sportcoats
  
  Sportcoats
  Suits
  Tuxedos
  Suit Vests
  All
- Sweaters
  
  Sweaters
  Sweater Vests
  All
- Sweatshirts & Hoodies
  
  Sweatshirts
  Hoodies
  All
- Team Apparel
  
  Jerseys
  T-Shirts
  Jackets
  Hoodies
  Sweatshirts
  Hats
  All
About
Consignment
Journal
Lookbook

Facebook
Instagram

Search

Newman & Co. Consignment

Shop
- Buy Gift Cards Here!
- New Arrivals
- Accessories
  
  Bags/Luggage
  Wallets
  Soap/Skincare
  Ties
  Sunglasses
  Belts & Belt Buckles
  Cologne
  Glasses
  Readers
  Hats
  Knives
  Misc. Items
  Gloves
  All
- Athletic Wear
  
  T-Shirts
  Long Sleeve T-Shirts
  Pullovers
  Pants
  Shorts
  Jackets
  All
- Furniture
- Home Decor
- Jewelry
  
  Watches
  Cufflinks
  Rings
  Necklaces
  All
- Motorcycle Gear
  
  Jackets
  T-Shirts
  Boots
  Jeans
  Chaps
  Helmets
  Accessories
  All
- Outerwear
  
  Jackets
  Coats
  Pullovers
  Vests
  All
- Pants & Jeans
  
  Jeans
  Pants
  Athletic Pants
  All
- Shirts
  
  Short Sleeve
  Casual Shirts
  Dress Shirts
  All
- Shoes
  
  Shoes
  Sneakers
  Sandals
  Boots
  All
- Shorts
  
  Casual Shorts
  Athletic Shorts
  Swimwear
  All
- Suits & Sportcoats
  
  Sportcoats
  Suits
  Tuxedos
  Suit Vests
  All
- Sweaters
  
  Sweaters
  Sweater Vests
  All
- Sweatshirts & Hoodies
  
  Sweatshirts
  Hoodies
  All
- Team Apparel
  
  Jerseys
  T-Shirts
  Jackets
  Hoodies
  Sweatshirts
  Hats
  All
About
Consignment
Journal
Lookbook

Search

Item added to your cart

View cart

Collection: Shoes

Sort by:

76 products

Filter:

Brand (0)

Brand

Size (0)

Size

8 (2 products)
8.5 (2 products)
9 (6 products)
9.5 (1 product)
10 (19 products)
10.5 (10 products)
11 (16 products)
11.5 (6 products)
12 (7 products)
13 (6 products)
11D (1 product)

8 (2 products)
8.5 (2 products)
9 (6 products)
9.5 (1 product)
10 (19 products)
10.5 (10 products)
11 (16 products)
11.5 (6 products)
12 (7 products)
13 (6 products)
11D (1 product)

Color (0)

Color

Black (17 products)
BlkGry (1 product)
Blue (1 product)
Brown (25 products)
Brown Leather (1 product)
Brown Suede (2 products)
Brown/Navy (1 product)
Burgundy (1 product)
Charcoal (1 product)
Cognac (1 product)
Green (2 products)
Grey (4 products)
Lavender (1 product)
Navy (2 products)
Navy Suede (1 product)
Sand (1 product)
Tan (8 products)
Tan Suede (2 products)
TanBrn (1 product)
White (3 products)

Black (17 products)
BlkGry (1 product)
Blue (1 product)
Brown (25 products)
Brown Leather (1 product)
Brown Suede (2 products)
Brown/Navy (1 product)
Burgundy (1 product)
Charcoal (1 product)
Cognac (1 product)
Green (2 products)
Grey (4 products)
Lavender (1 product)
Navy (2 products)
Navy Suede (1 product)
Sand (1 product)
Tan (8 products)
Tan Suede (2 products)
TanBrn (1 product)
White (3 products)

Price

The highest price is $410.00

$

From

To

Sort by:

Filter and sort Filter

Filter and sort

Filter

76 products

Brand

Clear

Size

8 (2 products)
8.5 (2 products)
9 (6 products)
9.5 (1 products)
10 (19 products)
10.5 (10 products)
11 (16 products)
11.5 (6 products)
12 (7 products)
13 (6 products)
11D (1 products)

Clear

Color

Black (17 products)
BlkGry (1 products)
Blue (1 products)
Brown (25 products)
Brown Leather (1 products)
Brown Suede (2 products)
Brown/Navy (1 products)
Burgundy (1 products)
Charcoal (1 products)
Cognac (1 products)
Green (2 products)
Grey (4 products)
Lavender (1 products)
Navy (2 products)
Navy Suede (1 products)
Sand (1 products)
Tan (8 products)
Tan Suede (2 products)
TanBrn (1 products)
White (3 products)

Clear

Price

The highest price is $410.00

$

From

$

To

Clear

Sort by:

Remove all

76 products

Oak Street Bootmakers Loafers

Oak Street Bootmakers Loafers

Regular price $95.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $95.00 USD
Unit price per
Allen Edmonds Oxford Shoes

Allen Edmonds Oxford Shoes

Regular price $65.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $65.00 USD
Unit price per
Magnanni Single Monk Strap Shoes

Magnanni Single Monk Strap Shoes

Regular price $85.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $85.00 USD
Unit price per
Magnanni Double Monk Strap Shoes NIB

Magnanni Double Monk Strap Shoes NIB

Regular price $125.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $125.00 USD
Unit price per
Gucci Double Monk Strap Shoes

Gucci Double Monk Strap Shoes

Regular price $260.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $260.00 USD
Unit price per
Taft "The Clint" Shoe

Taft "The Clint" Shoe

Regular price $105.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $105.00 USD
Unit price per
JB Ander Venetian Slipper

JB Ander Venetian Slipper

Regular price $125.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $125.00 USD
Unit price per
Allen Edmonds Shoes

Allen Edmonds Shoes

Regular price $65.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $65.00 USD
Unit price per
Beckett Simonon Oxford Shoes w/ Box

Beckett Simonon Oxford Shoes w/ Box

Regular price $85.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $85.00 USD
Unit price per
Jack Erwin Belgian Loafers w/ Box

Jack Erwin Belgian Loafers w/ Box

Regular price $53.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $53.00 USD
Unit price per
Luca Terra Loafers

Luca Terra Loafers

Regular price $105.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $105.00 USD
Unit price per
Brooks Brothers Shoes

Brooks Brothers Shoes

Regular price $75.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $75.00 USD
Unit price per
Taylor Stitch Loafers

Taylor Stitch Loafers

Regular price $155.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $155.00 USD
Unit price per
Clae Sneakers

Clae Sneakers

Regular price $65.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $65.00 USD
Unit price per
Ferragamo Loafers

Ferragamo Loafers

Regular price $155.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $155.00 USD
Unit price per
Allen Edmonds Loafers

Allen Edmonds Loafers

Regular price $65.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $65.00 USD
Unit price per
Clarks Chukka

Clarks Chukka

Regular price $48.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $48.00 USD
Unit price per
Ferragamo Oxford Shoes

Ferragamo Oxford Shoes

Regular price $155.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $155.00 USD
Unit price per
Allen Edmonds Neumok 2.0 Wingtip Oxford Shoes w/ Box

Allen Edmonds Neumok 2.0 Wingtip Oxford Shoes w/ Box

Regular price $85.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $85.00 USD
Unit price per
Johnnie-O Suede Loafers

Johnnie-O Suede Loafers

Regular price $53.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $53.00 USD
Unit price per
Johnnie-O Moccasins

Johnnie-O Moccasins

Regular price $53.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $53.00 USD
Unit price per
Tod's Loafers

Tod's Loafers

Regular price $95.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $95.00 USD
Unit price per
Oak Street Shoes

Oak Street Shoes

Regular price $165.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $165.00 USD
Unit price per
To Boot New York Shoes

To Boot New York Shoes

Regular price $65.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $65.00 USD
Unit price per

1
2
3
4

720 E 65th Street Indianapolis, IN 46220

317-253-2533

info@NewmanCo.shop

Information

Contact Us
Join Our Team
FAQ
Shipping & Returns
Terms & Conditions
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service
Visit Our Women's Store!

Hours

Shopping:

Mon-Sat: 10am-6pm

Sun: 12pm-5pm

Consigning:

Mon-Fri: 10:30am-5:30pm

Sun: 12:30pm-4:30pm

*Consignments Not Accepted On Saturdays

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Email

Facebook
Instagram

© 2025, Newman & Co. Consignment Powered by Shopify

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Opens in a new window.